This site is published by Medrecords AI, which makes 1 of the products it covers. We say which one wherever it appears. How we handle that.

QME Records Review

Worked example: pricing a messy QME record file

By Ahmed Jemaa, Co-Founder and CEO of Medrecords AI. Updated .

Result: on this synthetic file, 1,055 pages arrive but 970 are billable: 85 came without a sender's declaration. The ML201 bill is $4,325 if the 140 duplicate pages are counted and $3,905 if they aren't. The regulation doesn't say which is right, so the log has to show both numbers.

Limits: Not legal or billing advice. California rules are quoted as read on 2026-11-19 from dir.ca.gov and leginfo.legislature.ca.gov; verify the current text there before you bill, sign or serve, and ask counsel about your case.

Synthetic, no real patient. Every name, date and page count on this page is invented to show how the rules interact. The same numbers are preloaded in the calculator.

The file as it arrives

A panel QME in orthopedics is scheduled for an ML201 on a claimed right shoulder injury. 3 productions arrive before the exam:

BatchFromContentsDeclarationAttested
AClaims administratorClinic and therapy notes, imaging reports, the employer's first report, 2 deposition transcriptsYes, with 8 CCR 35(c) log640 pages
BApplicant's attorneyTreating surgeon's records, MRI report, pharmacy historyYes310 pages
CTreating therapy office, by faxPhysical therapy notes, visits 14 to 30NoNone

Step 1: sort by declaration

Batches A and B carry 9793(n) declarations with page counts. Batch C does not. Under 9793(n), batch C can't be billed and isn't treated as received for the QME's record and report duties. The QME's office writes to the parties the day it arrives, noting that batch C came without a declaration and won't be reviewed until one is provided.

Billable so far: batches A and B. Set aside: 85 pages, which would have been worth $255 at $3.00.

Step 2: count pages the 9793(n) way

Batch A holds 640 sheets. 20 of them are deposition transcript sheets printed 2-up, 2 transcript pages to a sheet. The claims administrator counted sheets. 9793(n) counts condensed pages separately, so those 20 sheets are 40 pages.

BatchSheetsCondensed sheetsPages under 9793(n)AttestedDifference and reason
A64020 at 2 pages each660640+20: sender counted sheets, not condensed pages
B3100310310None
C85085 (not billable)NoneNo declaration

Step 3: flag duplicates

Comparing A and B, 140 pages in batch B repeat pages already in batch A: the MRI report, 6 months of clinic notes and the pharmacy printout. The QME reviewed them (you can't know a page is a copy without looking at it), but they add no new facts.

Neither 9793(n) nor 9795 mentions duplicates. So the QME can verify 970 pages reviewed, or adopt a policy of not billing repeats and verify 970 reviewed while billing on 830. Either way, the log records the 140.

Step 4: price it both ways

LineDuplicates countedDuplicates not billed
Declared pages reviewed970970
Pages billed toward the code970830
Included in ML201200200
ML-PRR pages770630
ML-PRR at $3.00$2,310.00$1,890.00
ML201-95 (124 x $16.25; -95 is identification only)$2,015.00$2,015.00
Total$4,325.00$3,905.00

The gap is $420, or 140 pages at $3.00. On a single file that's small. Across a year of files with 2 sides sending overlapping records, it adds up, and it's exactly what a payer-side page-count review looks for.

Step 5: write it up

The report's record section lists batches A and B item by item and summarizes them (8 CCR 41), notes that batch C was received without a declaration and not reviewed, and carries the verification. Using the duplicates-counted figures, the calculator's sample wording reads:

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that I reviewed a total of 970 pages of records as part of this medical-legal evaluation and the preparation of this report. A further 85 pages were received without the declaration required by 8 CCR 9793(n) and are not included in this count.

The page-count log, from the declarations page template, goes in the case file with the 20-page condensed difference and the 140 duplicates written down.

Step 6: what happens to batch C

4 weeks after the report is served, the therapy office's records come back from the applicant's attorney with a 9793(n) declaration (85 pages), along with a request for a supplemental report and 40 pages of new records. Under the ML203 entry, the per-page charge covers pages received as part of the supplemental request: 125 pages, minus 50 included, is 75 pages at $3.00, or $225, plus $650: $875.

A payer could argue that batch C was "available" before the first report, which would bar the supplemental fee. 9793(n) says undeclared records are not considered available or received for the physician's duties, which supports the QME's position. This is the kind of call where the log and the dated letter to the parties from step 1 matter more than the arithmetic.

Worked example questions

Why are the undeclared pages not in the verification total?

Because 8 CCR 9793(n) says documents without the sender's declaration are not billable and not considered received. The sample verification lists them separately so the report is clear about what arrived.

Would an AME modifier change this bill?

Only the evaluation line. With -94, the ML201 becomes $2,720.25; the ML-PRR line stays $2,310 or $1,890, because 9795(d) keeps modifiers off page charges.